Educational Psychology / Unit 6 EDP 0524 review, 2 to 3 minutes
Teacher-Directed or Student-Centered?
The idea
The choice between teacher-directed and student-centered instruction depends on what kind of learning is sought, how much organization students need, and how much initiative they can take. Teacher-directed approaches, from lectures with advance organizers to mastery learning, direct instruction and Hunter's lesson model, organize information on students' behalf. They have strong evidence for teaching basic skills such as early reading and arithmetic when they are well designed and well implemented. Student-centered approaches, from inquiry and discovery learning to independent study and cooperative groups, give students more initiative and aim at complex thinking and transfer. Critics of teacher direction say it breeds passivity; critics of minimally guided discovery argue that novices learn less without guidance. The two families overlap in practice, and good teaching combines them.
In practice
Worked example: a unit on electric circuits. Students first need the vocabulary of current, voltage and resistance and the rule relating them; a short, well-organized explanation with checks for understanding teaches that efficiently. Then the class receives bulbs, batteries and wires and a question with no given answer: why do some bulbs glow dimmer than others? Groups investigate, with the teacher guiding by questions. The first half is teacher-directed, the second student-centered, and each does work the other does poorly.
Where people slip
The debate is often framed as a contest one side must win, but the evidence supports teacher direction for basic skills and leaves the value of minimal guidance for complex learning contested. Student-centered methods still need the teacher: independent study and reflection stay shallow without a teacher's response, and inquiry depends on guidance. Choosing well means asking which part of the learning each approach serves.
Your place on the trail
Every lesson rests on earlier ones and opens later ones. Tap any to jump.
Something wrong in this lesson? Flag it · Sources for Educational Psychology