Human Growth and Development / Unit 7 HGD 0957 review, 2 to 3 minutes
Mindset Theory
The idea
Carol Dweck's mindset theory contrasts two beliefs about ability. A growth mindset holds that abilities can improve with effort; a fixed mindset holds that they are set. A growth mindset is associated with less anxiety and depression. In a national experiment, Yeager and colleagues found that a brief growth-mindset intervention led to better grades and more enrolment in advanced mathematics, especially where teachers endorsed the idea. The theory spread widely through schools. The picture has since grown more complicated. Yeager and Dweck themselves described findings on academic outcomes as mixed, and a twenty twenty-three meta-analysis by Macnamara and Burgoyne found that mindset interventions do not improve achievement. Critics add that the theory can underplay innate ability and structural factors, such as the resources a school has.
In practice
Two students failing the same mathematics test, one saying "I'm not a maths person" and the other saying "I haven't learned this yet," and the open question of what, beyond that belief, would change either student's next grade.
Where people slip
The misconception is that a growth mindset reliably raises grades. The associations are real, and one large, well-designed experiment found benefits under particular conditions, but a meta-analysis found interventions do not improve achievement on average. Both findings can be true: a small effect in some settings can vanish when many studies are averaged. Dweck's recommendations, praising effort, rewarding strategy and saying "not yet," are reported here as hers, not as advice. Unit one's warning applies: a correlation between mindset and grades does not show that changing mindset changes grades. A contested idea is taught with both halves. For the exam, know the two mindsets by definition, and know that the evidence on achievement is contested.
Your place on the trail
Every lesson rests on earlier ones and opens later ones. Tap any to jump.
Unlocks
- Nothing yet depends on this.
Something wrong in this lesson? Flag it · Sources for Human Growth and Development