Skip to main content
SWStudyWalks Search

Human Growth and Development / Unit 6   HGD 0759 review, 2 to 3 minutes

The Marshmallow Test

Captions available

The idea

Around nineteen seventy, Walter Mischel and colleagues offered preschoolers a choice: one small treat now, or two if they could wait while the researcher left the room. Follow-up work by Mischel's group reported that children who waited longer at four went on to better academic performance and better health. Those findings travelled far beyond the laboratory, into claims that a young child's ability to wait predicts success in school, work and relationships. In twenty eighteen, Watts, Duncan and Quan re-examined the question. The associations they found were much smaller than the originals, and most became nonsignificant once they controlled for family background and early cognitive ability. A later study by Falk and colleagues found a positive but complicated link. The better-supported conclusion is that family circumstances and early abilities shape both a child's waiting and the child's later outcomes.

In practice

Two four-year-olds at the same table, one eating the marshmallow at once and one waiting, with much of the difference between them traced to the homes and abilities they brought with them.

Where people slip

The misconception is that the marshmallow test predicts life success. Waiting is a real skill, and it does develop between three and six, so the original task still measures something. What collapsed is the leap from one afternoon's waiting to a whole life's outcomes. This is a lesson in unit one's third-variable problem: family background and early ability can drive both the waiting and the later success, so the link between them is not evidence that waiting causes success. A contested classic is taught with both halves: the task holds up as a measure, and the sweeping prediction does not.

Your place on the trail

Every lesson rests on earlier ones and opens later ones. Tap any to jump.

Unlocks

  • Nothing yet depends on this.

Something wrong in this lesson? Flag it  ·  Sources for Human Growth and Development