Ethics and Values / Unit 6 Ethics 287 worked example, 60 to 90 seconds
The Virtue-and-Care Check
The idea
The virtue-and-care check reads a choice in four steps: name the virtues and vices in play, locate each mean, ask what practical wisdom sees in the particulars, and ask what the relationships require.
In practice
A team lead discovers her closest colleague inflated results in a grant report. Step one, name the traits in play: honesty, loyalty, courage — and the vices waiting: betrayal on one side, complicity on the other. Step two, locate the means. Honesty's mean is not public denunciation at Friday's all-hands; loyalty's mean is not helping bury the numbers. Step three, practical wisdom in the particulars: a first offense by a colleague in crisis differs from a pattern; the funder's audit next month differs from no audit. Suppose it is a first offense, audit coming. Step four, the relationships: what does caring for this colleague require — protecting her from consequences, or refusing to let her become someone who falsifies? The check converges: go to the colleague first, insist the correction comes from her, accompany her when it does. Four steps, no arithmetic — and the answer names persons, not only acts.
Where people slip
The check needs honest trait-naming; call complicity "loyalty" and the method dies at step one.
Your place on the trail
Every lesson rests on earlier ones and opens later ones. Tap any to jump.
Something wrong in this lesson? Flag it · Sources for Ethics and Values