Ethics and Values / Unit 8 Ethics 402 worked example, 60 to 90 seconds
Running a Case File
The idea
A case file works any applied dispute in five moves: fix the undisputed facts, flag the disputed ones, list the affected and their interests, run each side's strongest argument, and locate the values line for the reader.
In practice
Take a city's proposed facial-recognition contract. Move one, undisputed facts: the cameras exist, the contract's terms are public. Move two, disputed facts, flagged as such: accuracy rates across faces, projected crime effects — fact questions, sent to evidence, not to shouting. Move three, the affected: residents scanned, victims of crimes solved and unsolved, officers, the wrongly flagged. Move four, strongest arguments — both sides hire their best lawyer: for, the protection of the vulnerable and the utility audit's honest sums; against, consent never asked, opacity unanswerable, the like-cases worry automated. Move five, the values line: after every fact resolves, the sides still divide over what security may cost in being watched — name that line and stop. The file ends where the viewer's own weighing begins; a case file that announces the verdict has quietly become a press release.
Where people slip
Move two is where most public arguments die; flag disputed facts or join the shouting.
Your place on the trail
Every lesson rests on earlier ones and opens later ones. Tap any to jump.
Something wrong in this lesson? Flag it · Sources for Ethics and Values