Skip to main content

Running the Universalization Test

This video presents the same text shown beside it, spoken and on screen. It adds nothing the text does not say.

State

The universalization test runs in four steps: state the maxim honestly, universalize it, check whether the universal version destroys itself, and if not, check whether anyone could will it.

Show

Take the exhausted student's maxim: "copy homework when behind." Step one is already done — and honesty matters; "copy this once" hides the policy. Step two, universalize: everyone behind copies. Step three, contradiction check: universal copying ends homework's function as practice and signal — copied homework becomes worthless to copy, and the maxim eats its own tool. Fail: a perfect duty stands against it. Compare "never help classmates when busy." Universalized, it survives — study groups end, nobody's plan collapses. Step four, the will check: could anyone will a world of guaranteed unhelp, knowing she will someday need help? Willing it contradicts what every rational agent must also will. Fail again — but softer: an imperfect duty, with latitude. Two failures, two different duties, one method — and the honesty of step one is where the method is won or lost.

Watch for

The test grades maxims, not outcomes; a maxim dressed to pass has already failed step one.