Skip to main content

The Gorge Trap

This video presents the same text shown beside it, spoken and on screen. It adds nothing the text does not say.

State

One purpose-built map shows greedy selection walking into a trap that an admissible, even accurate, estimate cannot prevent.

Show

A hiking trip, Camp to Lodge, gorge between. Trails: Camp–Cliff, 1 kilometer; Cliff–Lodge, a 10-kilometer switchback; Camp–Bridge, 3; Bridge–Lodge, 3. The Cliff sits directly across the gorge from the Lodge, so the straight-line estimates read Cliff 1, Bridge 2, Camp 3 — all honest. Run greedy: from Camp the frontier holds Camp–Cliff, estimate 1, and Camp–Bridge, estimate 2. Greedy takes the Cliff. The only extension reaches the Lodge, and greedy returns Camp–Cliff–Lodge: 11 kilometers, against the 6 of Camp–Bridge–Lodge. The estimate was admissible and locally accurate — and the trap sprang anyway, because greedy never glanced at the meter running on the past.

Watch for

The failure is the strategy's, not the estimate's — the same numbers serve a better selector perfectly.