Skip to main content

The Either-Or Wall

This video presents the same text shown beside it, spoken and on screen. It adds nothing the text does not say.

State

Four lines of arithmetic prove that no perceptron — trained, hand-set, or inspired — can sort an either-or-but-not-both pattern.

Show

Suppose a stall sells out when festival or weekend but not both. Code the cases: neither — no; festival alone — yes; weekend alone — yes; both — no. Now suppose knobs exist: balance b, weights f and w. The no at neither requires b at most zero. The yes at festival alone requires b plus f above zero. The yes at weekend alone requires b plus w above zero. The no at both requires b plus f plus w at most zero. Add the two middle lines: twice b, plus f, plus w, exceeds zero. But the last line caps f plus w at minus b, so the sum is at most b — and the first line caps b at zero. A number above zero and at most zero: no such number exists, so no such knobs exist. The wall is proof-backed, not a matter of more training.

Watch for

The impossibility belongs to the single cut, not to the pattern — the pattern is easy for two questions in a row.